header image

Ahoy!

Earlier today I ran into something I haven’t encountered in years. I was downloading a massive Photoshop composition and was informed by Windows that I didn’t have adequate storage. Considering the size of my drives and how psycho I am about keeping things lean, this came as something of a surprise.

It would seem that my children have discovered BitTorrent and The Pirate Bay — to the tune of forty gigs.

This opens up a whole can of worms. My guys haven’t the slightest concept of intellectual property. Music has always been free for them and they firmly believe that they are entitled to download anything they damn well please. I find myself going into a great deal of detail (I even made them read a EULA) about the difference between licensing something and owning something. Then again, try telling a kid who has saved his hard earned money that he doesn’t really own the box set of CD’s he just bought.

My children are not dishonest. They do not lack a grasp of nuance and will, almost always, make the right decision. I’ve done a pretty good job with the Golden Rule and the right vs. wrong thing. However, they seem truly incapable of understanding that music and video can be owned and that they are expected to pay for entertainment.

They just aren’t getting it and when my eleven year-old asks how someone can own beautiful music, I have to wonder if she doesn’t have a point. I asked her how she would feel if someone took her art and her response was: “I would just make more and give it to them.”

It doesn’t help that they have good taste and it’s kind of nice having my own radio station.


Your comments

Very interesting. A lot of kids (at least from our generations) like the idea of being a star and living in a big house, etc. Perhaps you could try to frame your response with that? (Not saying that is the right thing, just trying to find a way to relate to them, and I think they can all relate to celebrities.)

Dunno, just thinking out loud. Good luck, I have a feeling you’re going to need it.

— evening · Dec 14, 05:04 PM · #

That’s not a bad idea, except they are total hippies. The kids couldn’t care less about big houses and bling.

Also, if it wasn’t clear, I’m somewhat ambivalent about copyright law myself. I want artists to be paid. I want people to pay me. I get grouchy when people use my work without compensating me. Then again, there are some real issues concerning livelihood and DRM that need to be addressed on another level. I don’t know what the solution is, but am certain that the ham-handed RIAA model isn’t one of them.

Al · Dec 14, 05:27 PM · #

Being a musician and a song-writer, I have always respected Woody Guthrie’s statement:

“This song is Copyrighted in U.S., under Seal of Copyright # 154085, for a period of 28 years, and anybody caught singin’ it without our permission, will be mighty good friends of ourn, cause we don’t give a dern. Publish it. Write it. Sing it. Swing to it. Yodel it. We wrote it, that’s all we wanted to do.”

It might be a surprise to find that most artists see very little from their work. The profit mostly from live performances. Perhaps I speak for myself but no one hates the record industry more than musicians.

The more we close in, the fewer artists we’ll breed.

We Americans have a distorted few of ownership, whether it’s in regards to music, land, or people. Often times our life lesson is finding out that when we grab a hold of something too tightly, it’s flown.

I am not a father, but if it’s any worth to say that I’d might suggest simply instilling the principles of lending and borrowing and also embrace the gift of giving.

— St. · Dec 16, 07:43 PM · #

Add a comment?

Name:

Email:

URL:

Message:

About this entry

This is an individual entry and was posted December 14, 2007.

This entry is tagged with: , ,

Search

Related entries

You may also be interested in:

About

me

I really need to put something here. Something about myself, something about this site. Something.

Maybe right after I add site navigation... say, a week from never.

Credits

This site is powered by Textpattern and the fine folks at Joyent. The stylesheet is derived from Harry Roberts wonderful Typogridphy.

Popular Tags

art, bazoomi, cartography, christmas, css, design, ephemera, family, internet, kids, law, media, music, photography, photos, photoshop, politics, privacy, recovery, schenectady, school, science, silly, software, summer, typography, web design, web development